1 or 2? RRoDeathstar

Hey so, little retro side project of mine. (I call it retro because it's been on my comp over over a year and I haven't taken it out and worked on it ok, so not really retro, but kinda)

ANYWAYS! Need some advice/help, what do you think? 1 or two?

1 being the one with the extra dark shadow, two being the one with the extra red lighting.

If neither that works too, let me know, this is for a side project of mine, all feedback is appreciated, even if just a word or two, or that it sucks or something.